Quotation, or plagiarism? An interview

  • Insight

November 24, 2021

Good Law Logo image

Editorial

Person holding large stack of papers in office

Partner Sander Verbeek of Good Law spoke to Boekenbusiness about the limits of copyright for writers. Many writers know that plagiarism is prohibited, but are still left with questions. 

Partner Sander Verbeek of Good Law spoke to Boekenbusiness about the limits of copyright for writers. Many non-fiction writers know that plagiarism is prohibited, but are still left with questions. For example, where is the line between quoting and infringing? What about copying tables or models? And what do you do if you cannot trace all the sources?

Not an exact science

Copyright law leaves room for interpretation, Verbeek explains. ‘The law is not an exact science,’ he says, ‘not a matter of one plus one is two.’ Discussions about books and citations rarely end up in court, as it is often too costly. Nevertheless, it is still important to proceed carefully and understand what is and is not allowed.

Verbeek stresses that ideas are free, but their elaboration is protected. That means you can use the gist of a theory, but copying texts or models verbatim without permission is not allowed. ‘Write a theory in your own words and add your own insights,’ he advises. Photos and illustrations should also not be used without permission. There must be a direct functional relationship with your text, and the source must always be mentioned.

Practical tips for non-fiction writers

According to Verbeek, it is important to keep track of what sources you use during the writing process. A digital diary or overview of quotes and sources can prevent many problems later on. In doubt about a quote or takeover? Then a disclaimer is a handy way to show responsibility. “Indicate that you did your best to arrange everything correctly, and offer to discuss any rights,” says Verbeek.

Prevention is better than cure

With clear source citations and your own point of view, you can minimise the risk of copyright claims. Still, prevention is always better. Verbeek advises writers to seek advice from a specialist at an early stage. “Good preparation prevents a lot of hassle,” he says.

Want to read all 15 questions and answers? You can find the full article on the Book Business website.

Recent insights

Freeriders in trouble: just compensation for Dassault

The North Holland District Court awarded Dassault Systèmes damages based on lost licence revenue. Hooks Creative and Soopl used SolidWorks without a licence and thus infringed copyright.

Insight

New: faster and more effective dispute resolution for shareholders

The Dispute Resolution and Clarification of Admissibility Requirements Survey Procedure Act (Wagevoe) makes it easier to settle shareholder disputes quickly and effectively.

News

Geoblocking and copyright: how far does the protection extend?

The Supreme Court asks the EU Court of Justice to clarify the legal status of geoblocking and VPNs in copyrighted works. What does this mean for online publications?

Insight

Deel dit artikel

White sneakers with yellow pants on tiled floor

Would you like to make an appointment?

For an appointment with one of our lawyers, for advice or orientation, we would be happy to welcome you to our office in Ouderkerk aan de Amstel or we will come to you.

  • Top players in the market
  • Always high quality
  • Expert and discreet

No spam, ever.